When you list your home, one of the first decisions we make together is whether to hold offers until a set date, or take them as they come. It sounds like a detail. It is actually one of the biggest strategic choices in the whole sale, and it can work brilliantly or backfire.
Here is how it works in Ontario, the rules that protect everyone, and how I decide which approach fits a home.
What holding offers means
Holding offers means we list the home and announce a specific date and time when we will review offers, usually about a week after the listing goes live. Until then, buyers can book showings, do their homework, and get their financing in order, but we are not responding to offers.
The idea is simple. Instead of the first buyer through the door setting the terms, every interested buyer gets a fair chance to see the home and put their best foot forward on the same evening. When demand is strong, that competition can lift the price and improve the terms.
When it works, and when it does not
Holding offers works when demand is strong. A well-priced home in a popular area, in a season with active buyers, that will draw a lot of showings. That is when several buyers show up on the same night.
It can backfire when demand is soft. If the market is slow, or the home appeals to a narrower group of buyers, an offer date can come and go with no offers at all. That does not mean the home will not sell. It does mean you have lost a week of momentum, and buyers watching the listing know the offer night was quiet.
Pricing is part of this strategy. An offer date usually pairs with a price set to attract attention, which only works if the market is there to compete. I explain how I set prices in the pricing post, and why the start of a listing matters so much in the first two weeks post.
The rules that protect buyers and sellers
Ontario has clear rules for competing offers, and they are worth knowing on either side.
The number of offers must be disclosed. The seller's brokerage has to tell every buyer who has made a written offer how many competing written offers there are. A verbal offer, or someone saying they plan to make an offer, does not count.
The contents are the seller's choice. Since December 1, 2023, a seller can direct their brokerage, in writing, to share the contents of competing offers, such as the highest price or the closing dates, with all the buyers. It is optional. The traditional blind process, where buyers do not see each other's offers, is still allowed. Either way, personal information about the buyers is never shared.
One thing buyers often do not realise: the seller can change that choice at any time. A seller can start by sharing offer details and later switch to a blind process, or the other way around, and there is no requirement to give advance notice. If you are buying, assume the rules of the night can change, and write the offer you would be comfortable with either way.
Offers must be in writing. A conversation, a text, or a promise is not an offer. Only written, signed offers are counted and presented.
Bully offers
Sometimes a buyer does not want to wait for the offer date. They submit a pre-emptive offer, often called a bully offer, before the offer date, usually with a short deadline, hoping to buy the home before anyone else gets the chance.
You do not have to look at it, and this is decided before you list, not on the night. When you hold offers, your agent needs your instructions in a written direction, and RECO, the provincial regulator, expects that direction to spell out how you want pre-emptive offers handled: whether you want to hear about them, and whether you would consider one. A one-line note on the listing saying you reserve the right to look at pre-emptive offers is not enough on its own.
You can change your mind, but it has to be done properly. If you said no pre-emptive offers and then want to consider one, you sign a new written direction first. Your agent then updates the listing and must notify, in writing, everyone who has shown interest in the home, including buyers who booked or attended a showing, that a pre-emptive offer has arrived and of any new offer time, so they have a fair chance to compete. A bully offer is worth considering when it is genuinely strong and showing activity suggests the offer date might not beat it. It is worth refusing when the home is drawing heavy interest.
Offer night
On the night, offers are presented, and we look at much more than price. Deposit size, conditions, closing date, and the strength of the buyer's financing all matter. A slightly lower offer with no conditions and a closing date that fits your plans can be the better deal. I wrote about how to judge the terms in the offer conditions post.
From there, you can accept one offer, sign back one offer with changes, or, in some cases, ask the buyers to improve their offers. The approach depends on how close the offers are and how many there are.
If offer night is quiet
If no offers come in, the listing simply continues, and offers can be accepted at any time. The key is to respond quickly. Look honestly at the showing feedback and the price, adjust if needed, and keep the momentum. A quiet offer night is information, and the sellers who do best are the ones who listen to it rather than waiting and hoping.
The takeaway
Holding offers is a tool, not a rule. In a strong market with a well-priced home, it can produce competition and a great result. In a slower market, taking offers as they come can be the smarter play. The right choice depends on your home, your price, and the market the week you list.
If you are thinking about selling in Burlington or Hamilton, that is one of the first strategy calls we will make together, based on real showing activity and the current market. You can start the conversation here.