This calculator plays out both lives month by month: the owner pays the mortgage, taxes, and the roof; the renter invests the down payment and the monthly difference. No thumb on the scale — the numbers decide.
Either one lets an insured mortgage run 30 years instead of 25. CMHC adds 0.20% to the premium for it.
3% is a conservative default. GTA home prices averaged about 6% a year from 1980 to 2025 (TRREB), so try a higher number to see how it changes the result
Property tax estimated at about 0.59% of today's value per year, allowing for 2016-based assessments. 2026 final urban rate, including Halton Region and education. Rural areas pay slightly less.
The rule of thumb is 1% to 2%: roofs, windows, and furnaces are real costs renters never pay
Leave at zero for a freehold house or townhouse
The place you would actually rent, even if it is smaller than the one you would buy
The model buys with Ontario land transfer tax and CMHC insurance where they apply, keeps the home (no sale, so no selling costs are deducted anywhere), and assumes investment gains grow tax-sheltered (TFSA or RRSP) while the home sale is tax-free as a principal residence. Estimates for planning purposes only, not financial advice.
Month to month, renting almost always wins once you count the full cost of owning: mortgage interest, property tax, maintenance, insurance, and condo fees. The long game is different. Buying forces you to build equity with every payment, the home appreciates, and a principal residence sells tax-free in Canada. Renting only keeps up if you actually invest the monthly difference instead of spending it.
It charges the buyer everything real: Ontario land transfer tax and CMHC insurance on the way in, roughly 1% of the home's value per year in maintenance while you own, and if you pick a selling year, a typical 4% commission plus HST and legal on the way out. It also asks the uncomfortable question on the rent side: what share of the monthly savings does the renter actually invest? Set that to anything less than all of it and watch the answer change.
A broad, low-cost index fund like one tracking the S&P 500 has averaged 7% to 10% per year over long periods, before inflation. Something in the 6% to 7% range is a sober planning number. The comparison assumes those gains grow tax-sheltered in a TFSA or RRSP; in a regular taxable account the renter's edge shrinks further.
Over a decade, yes. Ontario's rent increase guideline capped most 2025 increases at 2.5%, but that protection only applies while you stay put, and buildings first occupied after November 15, 2018 are exempt entirely. Move — or rent somewhere newer — and you reset to market rent. A fixed-rate mortgage payment, by contrast, does not go up with the market.
That is one of the strongest honest cases for renting, and the calculator handles it: enter the rent for the place you would actually live in — say a two-bedroom condo — against the townhouse you would buy. The bigger the gap, the more capital the renter has to invest. Just be honest about whether that smaller place still works if your life changes.
Let's talk. No pressure, no pitch, just straight answers built on real local data.